The End of An Era
To write the story of Alex, I have to start with the story of Harvey.
Harvey was an australian shepherd that was my first dog as an adult. I got Harvey about 2 seconds after I got married the first time and we secured a little house in San Diego to which we were moving. As I grasped wildly at things that would prove that I had a family of my own and I all but begged for someone to love me Harvey, fit that bill.
It’s easy for me to see now how grossly unprepared I was for both wife and dog and my suspect motivations shame me a little, but it was what it was. Harvey was destructive in spectacular ways and never really listened much for reasons that I understand much more clearly in hindsight. I loved him fiercely though as I found that I really liked being depended upon by others.
So Harvey and I “grew up” together a bit. He became more independent as I grew to become a man. By the time I was 32 and my marriage broke apart I left it with a washer/dryer, a computer, my books, more debt than money, and Harvey. Harvey and I slept on a friend’s futon for a couple of months until I could get into an apartment that would take a dog bigger than 25 pounds. I found one in Pittsburg (which is a terrible place to live and really far from work). It was not a great situation for either of us as we were both trying to adjust to this new life we had.
Incrementally, I rebuilt my world into something better than I had before. I got a new job that had a future. I found Amy (with whom I also had a future). Together, we moved into a condo in Vallejo that was better than either of our apartments – and even though it still didn’t have a yard, there were two of us to take care of his needs. She got off around 3:30 back then so his day cooped up in the condo was relatively short. Not ideal, but getting better all the time.
A couple of years later we were finally able to get into a house with a yard and Amy and I still talk about how happy Harvey seemed just lying in the sun in the back yard, with his eyes closed, alternately sniffing the wind and napping.
I finally felt like our life was matching the needs of those that depended on us and my guilt fell away. Without the guilt, though, I could see Harvey more clearly as a willful dog that had no respect for our authority. It was impossible to get Harvey to do anything that didn’t have a tangible motivation explicitly for Harvey. You could train him to do almost anything using “treats” but he never stopped looking for the food in your hand if you wanted him to do something. This started to become frustrating as we realized we now had a life that had a structure to it that we wanted him to fit in to. I didn’t blame Harvey for being the dog that he became – I took responsibility for what I had done as a I learned about the proper raising of dogs from the Monks of New Skete and others over the years. At the same time, I felt that it was too much to ask a 9 year old dog to be something different than the highly independent dog that he had become. It just wasn’t a battle I was going to fight.
Amy and I both felt, though, that Harvey would benefit from having a companion during the days while we were at work and that we would certainly approach the raising of a dog differently at this point in our lives than I did in my unsettled 20’s.
So we got a friend for Harvey – Alex.
Alex was a border collie we got from Tunnel Hill border collies in Fort Bragg, CA. It was a good 4 hours from where we live. There were a hundred reasons not to get a border collie. We took a bunch of those online personality tests and we scored very high as a match for “labrador” and some other dogs that were somewhat less driven by a desire to have a “job” to do to be happy. The problem was that we just didn’t really like labs that much and in spite of his willfullness, Harvey was really smart and we definitely valued that. Plus we really liked the look of border collies….and the heart wants what the heart wants.
In Amy’s online meandering she found out that Tunnel Hill had a recent litter of puppies, the pictures of which she smartly posted online. They were, predictably, impossibly cute. By that weekend it was memorial day and we found ourselves driving the four hours to check them out. Little Alex, as he would become, seemed to give as good as he got in playing with the other puppies. He had a great personality, but was also very sweet so we threw down our money and made the long trek home.
We both felt terrible as Alex got very car sick on the drive home (it’s the windiest road I’ve ever driven on coming back from Fort Bragg) as this was not the positive bonding experience we wanted to start our lives with him with. (As Amy details elsewhere, it took well over a year to break the car sickness associations with Alex).
What we did want to do, though, was create a proper pecking order in our pack with Alex so he would see us as pack leaders. We did this in a variety of ways – but the first and foremost was that I took a week off of work and kept Alex on a leash tied to my belt. It didn’t take long for him to realize that he had to pay close attention to what I was doing so he didn’t get dragged around. It also had the added benefit of not letting him sneak off to pee in the guest room if he so desired. We bonded a lot in that first week and he never questioned his role in the pack. We did other kinds of dominance excercises designed to reinforce the role as well, and they worked like a charm.
He and Harvey also figured out pretty quickly which was more alpha between them, though. Even before Alex could reach all the way up to Harvey’s head, he would get up on his hind legs so he could wrestle more effectively with Harvey. It wasn’t long before Harvey would lie down and wrestle from his belly, seemingly accommodating Alex. Harvey never made the obvious move to snap at Alex or to show Alex who’s the boss, so Alex became the boss by default.
It was a nice situation – Alex deferred to us, Harvey deferred to Alex and would mostly follow Alex’s lead outside of competitive situations like ball or frisbee throwing. Harvey was very fast and virtually always beat Alex to the ball when we played in the backyard. We felt bad for Alex, but you can only do so much to try to fake Harvey out so Alex could get a turn. Harvey would also bark at you in frustration if you screwed around too much with the machinations and didn’t throw it when you were supposed to.
Harvey passed very suddenly when Alex was less than 2 and Harvey was only 10. Fluid filled the sack around his heart (pericardial effusion) putting a lot of pressure on it’s ability to pump. We had it drained, but it filled up again less than 24 hours later. They said there was nothing they could do and so we let him go.
It was devestating. We had gone through so much together and though he was idiosyncratic, at least, we loved him very much. The feeling of loss was profound.
We moved on, though. Alex didn’t seem overly depressed and adjusted pretty well to the change. In fact, now that he finally was able get to the frisbee without another dog in the way, he became quite a frisbee dog. He was a 65 pound dog - but a graceful 65 pounds – as he always chose to leap into the air to make the catch more spectacular rather than wait for it to come down as Harvey always did. I think he took pride in his frisbee skills.
Amy talked about this on her blog, but we also figured out a way to keep him busy when we didn’t feel like throwing the frisbee any longer by teaching him the names of a dozen or more different toys (plushy, monkey, foxy, bear, yeti, little red, big red, rabbit, chippy, rocky, stumpy, kitty…come to mind). Initially we got toys that have a little sound box inside it so when you pushed on the monkey’s belly he would make Monkey sounds. He really loved the way he could make his toys make sounds, but he would usually crush it relatively quickly from excessive exuberance and to keep him interested we started playing a bit of hide and go seek with them. He learned the names quickly. You just had to repeat it to him a few times with emphasis and it usually stuck. Any time he started looking a little bored, he would see me gather up an armful of toys to take upstairs for hidning. He figured out very quickly that the game was on and would get very excited, often racing upstairs to wait for me. He was joyful.
We dropped into regular routines all throughout the day. He would often wake me up just before my alarm was about to go off so I could take him down to do his business before I showered. He would usually lick the shower drops from my shins which I thought was charming and so would thank him. Once I was ready he would head downstairs with me where he went out to get the paper before I made our breakfasts.
When I headed out in the morning he would go to his bed and lie down so I could back out of the garage without worrying about him scurrying under the car, or something dangerous. There were getting home routines and going to bed routines. If there was anything Alex liked it was a job to do or a schedule to keep.
When Alex first got sick a couple of weeks ago, we didn’t even think he was sick. One eye was kind of squinty and I assumed he just poked him self with a branch from a bush as he was searching for a frisbee. Amy insisted on taking him to the vet anyway and they couldn’t really find anything wrong with him after running some tests. He was still squinty two days later though and he seemed more bothered by it. He wasn’t “smiling” any more as he usually did when he was happy or content. The vet didn’t have anything more to do for him so she suggested we take him out to UC Davis so they could look at him. Amy took him the next day and they thought it was Horner’s syndrome (it wasn’t) and the vet thought he might have hypothyroidism (he didn’t).
That night, and for the next ten days, he was up almost every hour with extreme thirst, extreme need to go potty, and otherwise needing of comfort. We went back to the vet in the morning with the new symptoms and they referred us the Animal Care Center in Rohnert Park. He saw an internist there who did an ultrasound on him that was clean. Then he saw an neurologist who wanted to do an MRI and a spinal tap. The results weren’t good – there was a mass in the lower part of his brain. They weren’t sure if it was cancer, inflammation, or infection. They prescribed a steroid and antibiotic which would have worked if it had been inflammation or infection.
We were briefly optimistic as he seemed to perk up just a little when we first started the drugs, but a few days later, 11 days after the first symptom, he could no longer eat his food. His lips were sagging and he couldn’t work his jaw properly. His tongue still worked and he was able to lick much of his food into his mouth, very gradually. The decline was apparent though – he wasn’t getting better, he was getting worse which meant it was cancer after all.
Amy and I knew that this was one of the things we were looking out for as a sign of things to come. We called the doctor and they assured us that there was nothing left to do. Chemo wouldn’t buy very much time relative to the potential quality of life so we decided that we had to say goodbye to Alex as well, 4 days shy of his 5th birthday.
Actually putting a dog “to sleep” as they like to call it is just a terrible thing to go through. The moments as you wait in the examining room with your dog, trying to provide comfort to him are full of portent as you know what’s coming even as you know that they don’t. Although you know you’re doing the right or really only thing that you can do, actually saying goodbye to someone you love and being the agent for their demise as well are both equally terrible.
So, they gave him an injection of anesthesia to put him to sleep (literally) and then enough of an overdose to stop his heart. I can remember holding his head in my hands whispering to him that everything is going to be ok, trying to hold back the tears, as he was overcome by the drugs and went down. I laid his head down on the blanket and broke down as the doctor informed us that his heart had stopped beating.
Now that most of the tears are gone, our house is painfully quiet. I realize now, more than ever, what a partner Alex was to me in almost everything I did around the house. I can’t even sit in a room without finding myself scanning for his presence. I eat breakfast alone now and go to get the paper alone. When I get up in the morning there’s no one depending on my rising and as I drive home I know there’s no one that’s that interested in my arrival. His loss weighs on me.
Looking back now on both of them, I think they were each the dog that I deserved for that stage of my life. As I grew up I had earned the right to have a great dog like Alex and I feel cheated that I didn’t get more time with him. I think he would have been a fantastic help with the twins once he knew what we needed from him and I think he would have really appreciated the kids as they grew up together. He would have been a great playmate and guardian….but that will never be.
Farewell, Alex. We’ll always miss you.